Hello Folks!!

I recently had a dicussion on the effectivenss of performance appraisals (which is also one of my favourite topics and my project work in a couple of organisations) and the role of the bosses as mentors, with many HR practitioners.

All that they had to say was that MBOs was this...

It is a miserable failure in India....

this is because of role ambiguity
bosses are unclear about assigning tasks & objectives....
though individual goals are being set by employees themselves, still many feel that their objectives are already fixed, which is not flexible to change

and also that individual goals not being linked with organisational goals...

In light of our discussion on the role of mentoring in achieving better performance, when there is inadequate support from bosses, there are unclear expectations..and this hinders performance...

Coaching and mentoring only would help...But in India though many organisations go for newer appraisal systems, there seems to be a great divide in training bosses to act as mentors and coaches, which is far beyond the traditional appraisal systems and evaluation.....

Would like to get your feedback in the line of thought...

Regards

Bindu